Interesting, and thought provoking discussion!
I've chosen to believe in the faith of Christianity in its orthodoxy, despite my commitment to science, and acceptance of evolution and dependence on reason.
For example, I agree it may not be likely that Jesus was born of a virgin, (from what I recall, this could be taken as a mistranslation by Matthew of the Hebrew word for "young woman"-- however in the end, I don't feel bad for holding two opposing views.
It's a dichotomy, it's complex, life is complex, things can be both particles and waves at the same time, and I like that. It's a kind of chaos, and I can live with that.
I don't expect others to, but I think a freedom comes from not trying to understand or needing to prove everything you believe.
Does that make anyone uncomfortable?