That was the point of my reply.
It is your right to vote down a post without being sure what the author meant. But when we enter into this voting thingy, we are simply trying to reinforce a particular behaviour (positively or negatively). Why do we want to modify other people's behaviour? Do they not have their right? This is why I avoid (as much as I can) that particular game. This is why I don't accuse people of trolling even when I suspect they are.
I am simply advocating evidenced based reasoning. I hope no one here is against this.
Here is an opinion from my heart-throb on Sheldrake.